Profiles of conformity to gender role norms and depression among adult Korean men

Socioeconomic polarization have consequences for men seeking a traditional male image; consequently, the pattern of conformity to gender role norms is changing. Taking into account an actor-oriented perspective, this study hypothesized that adherence to gender role norms would vary among male groups and would be associated with differences in mental health, specifically in terms of depressive symptoms. For verification, a Gender Roles and Health Survey was conducted with 897 Korean men aged 19–69 years between January and February 2022 to assess male gender roles, traditional gender role attitudes, and descriptive masculine norms, and to measure participants’ level of depressive symptoms using the 8-item Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression scale. Four latent profiles—“high conformity”, “medium conformity”, “non-conformity to gender stereotypes” and “non-conformity to male gender roles”—were identified. The non-conformity to male gender roles profile, which entails accepting traditional gender stereotypes, was associated with a significantly higher depression score. This profile also exhibited the characteristics of lower age, lower household income and being unmarried or not living with a partner. The non-conformity to gender stereotypes profile showed the lowest depression score. Based on the study findings, individuals who deviate from gender role norms, particularly in terms of self-ascribed masculinity, are more likely to experience depression. This suggests that the relationship between adherence to gender role norms and men’s mental health is complex and varied.

Gender norm conformity; Korean men; Depression; Anomie

[1] Robertson S, Gough B, Robinson M. Masculinities and health inequalities within neoliberal economies. Masculinity, Labour, and Neoliberalism. 2018; 13: 311–334.

[2] McDowell L, Bonner-Thompson C. The other side of coastal towns: young men’s precarious lives on the margins of England. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space. 2020; 52: 916–932.

[3] Griffith DM. Achieving men’s health equity. In Smalley KB, Warren JC, Fernandez MI (eds.) Health equity: a solutions-focused approach (pp. 197–215). 1st edn. Springer Publishing Company: New York, USA. 2020.

[4] Seidler ZE, Rice SM, Ogrodniczuk JS, Oliffe JL, Shaw JM, Dhillon HM. Men, masculinities, depression: Implications for mental health services from a Delphi expert consensus study. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice. 2019; 50: 51–61.

[5] Connell RW. Masculinities. 1st edn. University of California Press: Berkeley, Los Angeles. 1995.

[6] Vandello JA, Bosson JK. Hard won and easily lost: a review and synthesis of theory and research on precarious manhood. Psychology of Men & Masculinity. 2013; 14: 101–113.

[7] Griffith DM. Promoting men’s health equity. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2020; 14: 1557988320980184.

[8] Courtenay WH. Constructions of masculinity and their influence on men’s well-being: a theory of gender and health. Social Science & Medicine. 2000; 50: 1385–1401.

[9] Vandello JA, Wilkerson M, Bosson JK, Wiernik BM, Kosakowska-Berezecka N. Precarious manhood and men’s physical health around the world. Psychology of Men & Masculinities. 2023; 24: 1–15.

[10] Robertson S. “I’ve been like a coiled spring this last week”: embodied masculinity and health. Sociology of Health and Illness. 2006; 28: 433–456.

[11] de Visser RO, McDonnell EJ. “Man points”: masculine capital and young men’s health. Health Psychology. 2013; 32: 5–14.

[12] Wong YJ, Wang SY. Toward an integrative psychology of masculinities. Psychology of Men & Masculinities. 2022; 23: 285–298.

[13] Iwamoto DK, Brady J, Kaya A, Park A. Masculinity and depression: a longitudinal investigation of multidimensional masculine norms among college men. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2018; 12: 1873–1881.

[14] Levant RF, Powell WA. The gender role strain paradigm. The Psychology of Men and Masculinities (pp. 15–43). 1st edn. American Psychological Association: Washington, DC. 2017.

[15] Mahalik JR, Locke BD, Ludlow LH, Diemer MA, Scott, RP, Gottfried M, et al. Development of the conformity to masculine norms inventory. Psychology of Men & Masculinity. 2003; 4: 3–25.

[16] Woo S. What is the masculinity of Korean men? Concept mapping of masculinity. Korean Journal of Culture and Social Issues. 2019; 25: 203–229. (In Korean)

[17] Wong YJ, Ho MR, Wang SY, Miller IS. Meta-analyses of the relationship between conformity to masculine norms and mental health-related outcomes. Journal of Counseling Psychology. 2017; 64: 80–93.

[18] Hoy S. Beyond men behaving badly: a meta-ethnography of men’s perspectives on psychological distress and help seeking. International Journal of Men’s Health. 2012; 11: 202–226.

[19] Kaya A, Iwamoto DK, Brady J, Clinton L, Grivel M. The role of masculine norms and gender role conflict on prospective well-being among men. Psychology of Men & Masculinities. 2019; 20: 142–147.

[20] Sileo KM, Kershaw TS. Dimensions of masculine norms, depression, and mental health service utilization: results from a prospective cohort study among emerging adult men in the United States. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2020; 14: 1557988320906980.

[21] Canetto SS. Suicide: why are older men so vulnerable? Men and Masculinities. 2017; 20: 49–70.

[22] Van Doorn G, Teese R, Gill PR. Prospective associations between hegemonic masculinity and incident depression/depressive symptoms: results from a national sample of Australian emerging adult men. Personality and Individual Differences. 2021; 179: 110899.

[23] Hammer JH, Good GE. Positive psychology: an empirical examination of beneficial aspects of endorsement of masculine norms. Psychology of Men & Masculinity. 2010; 11: 303–318.

[24] Kim J, Choi H. Self-esteem as a mediator between instrumentality, gender role conflict and depression in Korean middle-aged men. The Korean Journal of Woman Psychology. 2007; 12: 145–160. (In Korean)

[25] Song R, Lee M-A. Gender role attitude and depressive symptoms: comparisons across gender and age groups. Korea Journal of Population Studies. 2012; 35: 87–116. (In Korean)

[26] Spendelow JS. Men’s self-reported coping strategies for depression: a systematic review of qualitative studies. Psychology of Men & Masculinity. 2015; 16: 439–447.

[27] Creighton G, Oliffe JL. Theorising masculinities and men’s health: a brief history with a view to practice. Health Sociology Review. 2010; 19: 409–418.

[28] Kim SY, Lee J, Wester SR, Fouad N. Do “manly” men believe other men are happier? Social comparison, masculine norms, and positive work-family spillover. Psychology of Men & Masculinities. 2020; 21: 251–265.

[29] McDermott RC, Addis M, Gazarian D, Eberhardt ST, Brasil KM. Masculine depression: a person-centric perspective. Psychology of Men & Masculinities. 2022; 23: 362–373.

[30] Milner A, Shields M, King T. The influence of masculine norms and mental health on health literacy among men: evidence from the ten to men study. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2019; 13: 1557988319873532.

[31] Ma KH, Moon HY, Cho SY, Kim R. Hegemonic masculinity and changing lives of men. Korean Women’s Development Institute: Seoul, Republic of Korea. 2017.

[32] Kilian R, Müller-Stierlin A, Söhner F, Beschoner P, Gündel H, Staiger T, et al. Masculinity norms and occupational role orientations in men treated for depression. PLOS ONE. 2020; 15: e0233764.

[33] Connell RW, Messerschmidt JW. Hegemonic masculinity: rethinking the concept. Gender & Society. 2005; 19: 829–859.

[34] Messerschmidt JW. Engendering gendered knowledge: assessing the academic appropriation of hegemonic masculinity. Men and Masculinities. 2012; 15: 56–76.

[35] Griffin B. Hegemonic masculinity as a historical problem. Gender & History. 2018; 30: 377–400.

[36] Wedgwood N, Connell R, Wood J. Deploying hegemonic masculinity: a study of uses of the concept in the journal Psychology of Men & Masculinities. Psychology of Men & Masculinities. 2022; 24: 83–93.

[37] Lapinski MK, Rimal RN. An explication of social norms. Communication Theory. 2005; 15: 127–147.

[38] Cialdini RB. Descriptive social norms as underappreciated sources of social control. Psychometrika. 2007; 72: 263–268.

[39] Bird CE, Rieker PP. Gender matters: an integrated model for understanding men’s and women’s health. Social Science & Medicine. 1999; 48: 745–755.

[40] Laurie T. Complicit masculinity and the serialization of violence: notes from Australian cinema. Continuum. 2022; 36: 64–83.

[41] Yi J. The age of depression: medicalization of melancholia and the meaning of autobiographical narrative discourse of depression. The Korean Journal of Humanities and the Social Sciences. 2022; 46: 125–152.

[42] K·Indicator. Suicide rate 2022. 2023. Available at: https://www.index.go.kr/unify/idx-info.do?idxCd=8040 (Accessed: 27 March 2023).

[43] Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service. Healthcare Bigdata Hub 2018. 2018. Available at: http://opendata.hira.or.kr/op/opc/olapHthInsRvStatInfo.do (Accessed: 28 March 2023).

[44] Ministry of Health and Welfare. Covid-19 National Mental Health Survey 2021. 2021. Available at: https://www.mohw.go.kr/react/al/sal0301vw.jsp?PAR_MENU_ID=04&MENU_ID=0403&page=1&CONT_SEQ=369669 (Accessed: 28 March 2023).

[45] Kim S, Lee Y. The discursive construction of men-the weak identity via online community. Journal of Korean Women’s Studies. 2017; 33: 67–107.

[46] Park MN, Min H, Jang TH. A study of male youth’s perception of misogyny: focused on Gangnam station murder case. Korean Journal of Communication Studies. 2019; 27: 85–111. (In Korean)

[47] Bae E. Gendering ‘young generation’ discourses: focusing on the concept of masculinity. Gender and Culture. 2015; 8: 7–41. (In Korean)

[48] Gunn V, Vives A, Zaupa A, Hernando-Rodriguez JC, Julià M, Kvart S, et al. Non-standard employment and unemployment during the COVID-19 crisis: economic and health findings from a six-country survey study. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2022; 19: 5865.

[49] Mills R, Zullig KJ, Theeke LA, Lander LR, Hobbs G.R, Herczyk J, et al. Assessing loneliness among adults receiving outpatient treatment with medication for opioid use disorder (MOUD). International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2022; 19: 13481.

[50] Radloff LS. The CES-D scale: a self-report depression scale for research in the general population. Applied Psychological Measurement. 1977; 1: 385–401.

[51] Turvey CL, Wallace RB, Herzog R. A revised CES-D measure of depressive symptoms and a DSM-based measure of major depressive episodes in the elderly. International Psychogeriatrics. 1999; 11: 139–148.

[52] Karim J, Weisz R, Bibi Z, ur Rehman S. Validation of the eight-item center for epidemiologic studies depression scale (CES-D) among older adults. Current Psychology. 2015; 34: 681–692.

[53] Beller J, Regidor E, Lostao L, Miething A, Kröger C, Safieddine B, et al. Decline of depressive symptoms in Europe: differential trends across the lifespan. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology. 2021; 56: 1249–1262.

[54] Levant R, Smalley K, Aupont M, House A, Richmond K, Noronha D. Initial validation of the male role norms inventory-revised (MRNI-R). The Journal of Men’s Studies. 2007; 15: 83–100.

[55] Levant RF, McDermott R, Parent MC, Alshabani N, Mahalik JR, Hammer JH. Development and evaluation of a new short form of the conformity to masculine norms inventory (CMNI-30). Journal of Counseling Psychology. 2020; 67: 622–636.

[56] Worthington RL, Whittaker TA. Scale development research: a content analysis and recommendations for best practices. The Counseling Psychologist. 2006; 34: 806–838.

[57] Park S, Jo E. Male gender role and adjustment of Korean men. Korean Journal of Psychological and Social Issues. 2002; 8: 77–103. (In Korean)

[58] Lee SY, Kim IS, Kim JH, Kim JA. Development of Korean male gender role conflict scale. The Women’s Studies. 2012; 82: 5–33.

[59] Cialdini RB, Trost MR. Social influence: social norms, conformity and compliance. In Gilbert DT, Fiske ST, Lindzey G. (eds.) The handbook of social psychology (pp. 151–192). 1st edn. McGraw-Hill: New York. 1998.

[60] Halimi M, Consuegra E, Struyven K, Engels N. A critical examination of the reliability and validity of a gender role attitude scale in Flanders (Belgium): what lessons can be learned? Sex Roles. 2018; 78: 423–438.

[61] Messner MA. The limits of “the male sex role”: an analysis of the men’s liberation and men’s rights movements’ discourse. Gender & Society. 1998; 12: 255–276.

[62] Vermeersch H, T'sjoen G, Kaufman JM, Vincke J, Van Houtte M. Gender ideology, same-sex peer group affiliation and the relationship between testosterone and dominance in adolescent boys and girls. Journal of Biosocial Science. 2010; 42: 463–475.

[63] Minimum Wage Commision. Analysis of real living cost for unmarried single workers 2022. 2022. Available at: http://minimumwage.go.kr/open/research/view.do?bultnId=4212&pageUnit=10&pageIndex=1&bultnCd=BB (Accessed: 29 March 2023).

[64] Lubke G, Muthén BO. Performance of factor mixture models as a function of model size, covariate effects, and class-specific parameters. Structural Equation Modeling: a Multidisciplinary Journal. 2007; 14: 26–47.

[65] Connell RW, Wood J. Globalization and business masculinities. Men and Masculinities. 2005; 7: 347–364.

[66] Kersten J. Culture, masculinities and violence against women. The British Journal of Criminology. 1996; 36: 381–395.

[67] Willer R, Rogalin CL, Conlon B, Wojnowicz MT. Overdoing gender: a test of the masculine overcompensation thesis. American Journal of Sociology. 2013; 118: 980–1022.

[68] Hadar-Shoval D, Alon-Tirosh M, Asraf K, Tannous-Haddad L, Tzischinsky O. The association between men’s mental health during COVID-19 and deterioration in economic status. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2022; 16: 15579883221082427.

[69] Jeong H, Park S, Kim J, Oh K, Yim HW. Mental health of Korean adults before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: a special report of the 2020 Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey. Epidemiology and Health. 2022; 44: e2022042.

[70] Simpson NJ, Oliffe JL, Rice SM, Kealy D, Seidler ZE, Ogrodniczuk JS. Social disconnection and psychological distress in canadian men during the COVID-19 pandemic. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2022; 16: 15579883221078145.

[71] Jewkes R, Morrell R, Hearn J, Lundqvist E, Blackbeard D, Lindegger G, et al. Hegemonic masculinity: combining theory and practice in gender interventions. Culture, Health & Sexuality. 2015; 17: 112–127.

[72] Elliott K. Caring masculinities: theorizing an emerging concept. Men and Masculinities. 2016; 19: 240–259.