Men's mental health and interventions tailored to masculinity: a scoping review

Masculinity norms, characterized by specific behaviors, thoughts and emotions that are considered socially appropriate for both Eastern and Western men, have been perceived as obstacles to seeking professional help, especially in situations where men are mentally distressed. This scoping review aimed to gain insight into the different factors that affect men’s mental health and explore the different types of interventions tailored to masculinity conventions. Research published between January 2018 and June 2023 was examined using keywords to extract relevant studies from PubMed, CINAHL, SCOPUS and Web of Science, with discussion and cross-checking by both authors. Twelve studies consisting of six randomized-controlled trials, four qualitative studies and two mixed method studies were identified. A variety of interventions were identified in this review, including soccer-related physical activity-based interventions, online interventions, therapeutic counseling interventions that integrate interviews and cognitive-behavioral group therapy, and interventions using expert networks. The need for online interventions that consider traditional masculinity norms in encouraging help-seeking behavior, and the effectiveness of support groups in providing a safe space for men to discuss their mental health, are key findings. As a public health issue, men’s mental well-being is substantially significant, and tailored interventions are needed to support men’s mental health. Therefore, the implementation of effective interventions and the active role of policy makers in promoting mental health awareness for men is also required. Based on these findings, strategies to engage men in mental health services, strengthen social support networks, and challenge harmful male stereotypes within healthcare settings and communities should be considered.

Masculinity; Men; Mental health; Scoping review

[1] Gough B, Novikova I. Mental health, men and culture: how do sociocultural constructions of masculinities relate to men’s mental health help-seeking behavior in the WHO European region? Technical report. World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe: Copenhagen. 2020.

[2] Mental Health America. Prevalence of mental health conditions in specific populations. 2021. Available at: https://mhanational.org/mentalhealthfacts (Accessed: 14 August 2023).

[3] Ellison JM, Semlow AR, Jaeger EC, Griffth DM. COVID-19 and mental health: addressing men’s mental health needs in the digital world. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2021; 15: 15579883211030021.

[4] McKenzie SK, Collings S, Jenkin G, River J. Masculinity, social connectedness, and mental health: men’s diverse patterns of practice. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2018; 12: 1247–1261.

[5] Robertson S, Gough B, Hanna E, Raine G, Robinson M, Seims A, et al. Successful mental health promotion with men: the evidence from ‘tacit knowledge’. Health Promotion International. 2018; 33: 334–344.

[6] Levant RF, Pryor S. The tough standard: the hard truths about masculinity and violence. 1st edn. Oxford University Press: Oxford, United Kingdom. 2020.

[7] Schofield T, Connell RW, Walker L, Wood JF, Butland DL. Understanding men’s health and illness: a gender-relations approach to policy, research, and practice. Journal of American College Health. 2000; 48: 247–256.

[8] Vickery A. ‘It’s made me feel less isolated because there are other people who are experiencing the same or very similar to you’: men’s experiences of using mental health support groups. Health & Social Care in the Community. 2022; 30: 2383–2391.

[9] Bryde Christensen A, Krohn S, Høj M, Poulsen S, Reinholt N, Arnfred S. “Men are not raised to share feelings” exploring male patients’ discourses on participating in group cognitive-behavioral therapy. The Journal of Men’s Studies. 2023; 31: 3–24.

[10] Pirkis J, Spittal MJ, Keogh L, Mousaferiadis T, Currier D. Masculinity and suicidal thinking. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology. 2017; 52: 319–327.

[11] Seidler ZE, Dawes AJ, Rice SM, Oliffe JL, Dhillon HM. The role of masculinity in men’s help-seeking for depression: a systematic review. Clinical Psychology Review. 2016; 49: 106–118.

[12] Pederson EL, Vogel DL. Male gender role conflict and willingness to seek counseling: testing a mediation model on college-aged men. Journal of Counseling Psychology. 2007; 54: 373–384.

[13] Eagly AH, Wood W. Social role theory. In van Lange PAM, Kruglanski AW, Higgins ET (eds.) Handbook of theories of social psychology. (pp. 458–476). 1st edn. SAGE Publications Ltd: London. 2012.

[14] McLeod S. Social identity theory: definition, history, examples, & facts. 2008. Available at: https://www.simplypsychology.org/social-identity-theory.html (Accessed: 14 August 2023).

[15] Hammer JH, Vogel DL, Heimerdinger-Edwards SR. Men’s help seeking: examination of differences across community size, education, and income. Psychology of Men & Masculinity. 2013; 14: 65–75.

[16] Frey JJ, Osteen PJ, Sharpe TL, Mosby AO, Joiner T, Ahmedani B, et al. Effectiveness of man therapy to reduce suicidal ideation and depression among working-age men: a randomized controlled trial. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior. 2023; 53: 137–153.

[17] Eggenberger L, Ehlert U, Walther A. New directions in male-tailored psychotherapy for depression. Frontiers in Psychology. 2023; 14: 1146078.

[18] Matthews LR, Gerald J, Jessup GM. Exploring men’s use of mental health support offered by an Australian employee assistance program (EAP): perspectives from a focus-group study with males working in blue- and white-collar industries. International Journal of Mental Health Systems. 2021; 15: 68.

[19] Rice S, Oliffe J, Seidler Z, Borschmann R, Pirkis J, Reavley N, et al. Gender norms and the mental health of boys and young men. The Lancet Public Health. 2021; 6: e541–e542.

[20] Seidler ZE, Rice SM, River J, Oliffe JL, Dhillon HM. Men’s mental health services: the case for a masculinities model. The Journal of Men’s Studies. 2018; 26: 92–104.

[21] Schlichthorst M, King K, Turnure J, Phelps A, Pirkis J. Engaging Australian men in masculinity and suicide—a concept test of social media materials and a website. Health Promotion Journal of Australia. 2019; 30: 390–401.

[22] King K, Schlichthorst M, Turnure J, Phelps A, Spittal MJ, Pirkis J. Evaluating the effectiveness of a website about masculinity and suicide to prompt help-seeking. Health Promotion Journal of Australia. 2019; 30: 381–389.

[23] Munn Z, Peters MDJ, Stern C, Tufanaru C, McArthur A, Aromataris E. Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach. BMC Medical Research Methodology. 2018; 18: 143.

[24] Gough D, Thomas J, Oliver S. Clarifying differences between review designs and methods. Systematic Reviews. 2012; 1: 28.

[25] Peters MDJ, Godfrey C, McInerney P, Khalil H, Larsen P, Marnie C, et al. Best practice guidance and reporting items for the development of scoping review protocols. JBI Evidence Synthesis. 2022; 20: 953–968.

[26] Rabie S, Tomlinson M, Almirol E, Stewart J, Skiti Z, Weiss RE, et al. Utilizing soccer for delivery of HIV and substance use prevention for young South African men: 6-month outcomes of a cluster randomized controlled trial. AIDS and Behavior. 2023; 27: 842–854.

[27] Walther A, Ehlert U, Schneeberger M, Eggenberger L, Fluckiger C, Komlenac N, et al. Evaluation of a male-specific psychotherapeutic program for major depressive disorder compared to cognitive behavioral therapy and waitlist: study protocol for a six-arm randomized clinical superiority trial examining depressed eugonadal and hypogonadal men receiving testosterone. Frontiers in Psychiatry. 2023; 14: 1129386.

[28] Watkins DC, Goodwill JR, Johnson NC, Casanova A, Wei T, Allen JO, et al. An online behavioral health intervention promoting mental health, manhood, and social support for young black men: the YBMen project. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2020; 14: 1557988320937215.

[29] Gilgoff JN, Wagner F, Frey JJ, Osteen PJ. Help-seeking and man therapy: the impact of an online suicide intervention. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior. 2023; 53: 154–162.

[30] Walther A, Eggenberger L. Evaluation of male-specific psychoeducation for major depressive disorder compared to cognitive behavioral therapy psychoeducation: a randomized controlled investigation in mentally distressed men. To be published in PsyArXiv Preprints. 2022. [Preprint].

[31] Giusto AM, Ayuku D, Puffer ES. Learn, engage, act, dedicate (LEAD): development and feasibility testing of a task-shifted intervention to improve alcohol use, depression and family engagement for fathers. International Journal of Mental Health systems. 2022; 16: 16.

[32] Dognin JS, Chen CK. The secret sorrows of men: impact of dynamic interpersonal therapy on ‘masculine depression’. Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy. 2018; 32: 181–196.

[33] Seaton CL, Bottorff JL, Jones-Bricker M, Oliffe JL, DeLeenheer D, Medhurst K. Men’s mental health promotion interventions: a scoping review. American Journal of Men’s Health. 2017; 11: 1823–1837.

[34] Robinson M, Robertson S, Steen M, Raine G, Day R. Doing and rethinking. Building resilience with men. Mental Health Review Journal. 2015; 20: 185–198.

[35] Wilks CR, Yee Ang S, Wang X, Arunagiri V, Ward-Ciesielski EF. Exploring preference to avoid or seek help in person and online among college students with suicidal ideation. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology. 2019; 38: 811–835.