Comparative effects of hypochlorous acid and povidone-iodine on infection and allergy risks in penile prosthesis surgery

Background: Penile prosthesis implantation carries an unavoidable risk of infection, which can lead to severe morbidity. This study aims to evaluate the efficacy of hypochlorous acid (HOCl) compared to povidone-iodine (PI) for surgical site antisepsis, with particular emphasis on infection prevention and allergic reaction rates. Methods: A retrospective analysis was conducted on 159 patients who underwent penile prosthesis implantation by a single surgeon. Patients were categorized into two groups: the PI group (n = 80, surgeries performed before 2023) and the HOCl group (n = 79, surgeries performed in 2023 and 2024). Postoperative infection rates and allergic reactions were recorded and statistically analyzed. Results: The number of infection and allergic reaction events was lower in the HOCl group (n = 4 and n = 1, respectively) compared to the PI group (n = 5 and n = 4, respectively), although the differences were not statistically significant. No cases required revision surgery due to infection and related interventions. HOCl demonstrated antimicrobial efficacy comparable to PI, while offering a substantial reduction in allergic reactions. Conclusions: HOCl appears to be an effective and well-tolerated antiseptic alternative to PI in penile prosthesis surgery. As the first study to investigate HOCl in this context, these findings provide a foundation for future research and clinical applications.

Hypochlorous acid; Povidin-iodine; Penile prosthesis surgery; Infection; Allergy

[1] Carvajal A, Benavides J, García-Perdomo HA, Henry GD. Risk factors associated with penile prosthesis infection: systematic review and meta-analysis. International Journal of Impotence Research. 2020; 32: 587–597.

[2] Köhler TS, Wilson SK. Wilson’s: pearls, perils and pitfalls of penile prosthesis surgery. 1st edn. Calvert McBride Publishers: Fort Smith, Arkansas. 2018.

[3] O’Rourke TK III, Erbella A, Zhang Y, Wosnitzer MS. Prevention, identification, and management of post-operative penile implant complications of infection, hematoma, and device malfunction. Translational Andrology and Urology. 2017; 6: S832–S848.

[4] Leow SKH, Knight D, Cooter R. Perioperative anaphylaxis to povidone-iodine in breast prosthesis surgery: a case report. Australasian Journal of Plastic Surgery. 2023; 6: 1–3.

[5] Kekul O, Ustun Y, Kömürcü Ö, Bilgin S, Karakaya D. Skin reaction related to povidone iodine use. Journal of Experimental & Clinical Medicine. 2021; 38: 389–392.

[6] Helo S, Bonakdar Hashemi M, Ziegelmann MJ, Lybbert DT, Piraino J, Guillen Lozoya AH, et al. Chlorhexidine gluconate application, diabetes, revision surgery, and extended operative time increase risk for penile implant infection. The Journal of Sexual Medicine. 2025; 22: 508–516.

[7] Sakarya S, Gunay N, Karakulak M, Ozturk B, Ertugrul B. Hypochlorous acid: an ideal wound care agent with powerful microbicidal, antibiofilm, and wound healing potency. Wounds Journal. 2014; 26: 342–350.

[8] Perchikov R, Cheliukanov M, Plekhanova Y, Tarasov S, Kharkova A, Butusov D, et al. Microbial biofilms: features of formation and potential for use in bioelectrochemical devices. Biosensors. 2024; 14: 302.

[9] Mu X, Wei X, Li Z, Wei M, Wei J. Does intraoperative wound irrigation with diluted povidone-iodine prevent surgical site infection in spine surgery? EFORT Open Reviews. 2024; 9: 1087–1096.

[10] Qadir Tantry I, Ali A, Mahmood R. Hypochlorous acid decreases antioxidant power, inhibits plasma membrane redox system and pathways of glucose metabolism in human red blood cells. Toxicology Research. 2021; 10: 264–271.

[11] Burian EA, Sabah L, Kirketerp-Møller K, Ibstedt E, Fazli MM, Gundersen G. The safety and antimicrobial properties of stabilized hypochlorous acid in acetic acid buffer for the treatment of acute wounds-a human pilot study and in vitro data. The International Journal of Lower Extremity Wounds. 2023; 22: 369–377.

[12] Pattison DI, Hawkins CL, Davies MJ. Hypochlorous acid-mediated protein oxidation: how important are chloramine transfer reactions and protein tertiary structure? Biochemistry. 2007; 46: 9853–9864.

[13] Murthy R, Eccleston D, Mckeown D, Parikh A, Shotter S. Improving aseptic injection standards in aesthetic clinical practice. Dermatologic Therapy. 2021; 34: e14416.

[14] Winter J, Ilbert M, Graf PC, Ozcelik D, Jakob U. Bleach activates a redox-regulated chaperone by oxidative protein unfolding. Cell. 2008; 135: 691–701.

[15] Cosentino M, Bianco M, Ruiz-Castañé E, Iafrate M. Treatment of penile prosthesis implant’s infection. Urologia Internationalis. 2020; 104: 542–545.

[16] Gökçe ON, Çetin K, Taş Ş, Alkan S, Dinç U. Hypochlorous acid: a novel agent against echinococcus granulosus protoscoleces. Infectious Diseases and Clinical Microbiology. 2023; 5: 158–164.

[17] Palau M, Muñoz E, Lujan E, Larrosa N, Gomis X, Márquez E, et al. In vitro and in vivo antimicrobial activity of hypochlorous acid against drug-resistant and biofilm-producing strains. Microbiology Spectrum. 2022; 10: e0236522.

[18] Mencucci R, Morelli A, Favuzza E, Galano A, Roszkowska AM, Cennamo M. Hypochlorous acid hygiene solution in patients affected by blepharitis: a prospective randomised study. BMJ Open Ophthalmology. 2023; 8: e001209.

[19] Shteynshlyuger A, Rabinowitz D. Salvage of infected penile prosthesis using novel high-pressure pulse irrigation system adapted to urological use in conjunction with a new antimicrobial solution. The Journal of Sexual Medicine. 2022; 19: S120.

[20] Tran AQ, Topilow N, Rong A, Persad PJ, Lee MC, Lee JH, et al. Comparison of skin antiseptic agents and the role of 0.01% hypochlorous acid. Aesthetic Surgery Journal. 2021; 41: 1170–1175.

[21] Gold MH, Andriessen A, Bhatia AC, Bitter P III, Chilukuri S, Cohen JL, et al. Topical stabilized hypochlorous acid: the future gold standard for wound care and scar management in dermatologic and plastic surgery procedures. Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology. 2020; 19: 270–277.

[22] Millones-Gómez PA, Novoa-Herrera M, Maurtua-Torres DJ, Bacilio-Amaranto RE, Requena-Mendizábal MF, Calla-Poma R, et al. Antibacterial effect of hypochlorous acid on bacteria associated with the formation of periodontal biofilms: an in vitro pilot study. Pesquisa Brasileira em Odontopediatria e Clínica Integrada. 2023; 23: e210078.

[23] Gon LM, de Campos CCC, Voris BRI, Passeri LA, Fregonesi A, Riccetto CLZ. A systematic review of penile prosthesis infection and meta-analysis of diabetes mellitus role. BMC Urology. 2021; 21: 35.

[24] Clayman E, Beauchamp Z, Troy J. Salvage of infected orthopedic hardware with intraoperative and postoperative hypochlorous acid instillations. ePlasty. 2023; 23: e1.